Neither way is wrong. Your drying room picks the trim.
Wet trim or dry trim: which one, and does it cost me smell?
GROWER ANSWER
Neither way is wrong. Wet trim means taking the leaves off right at the chop, while the plant is still fresh. Dry trim means hanging her with the leaves on and trimming after the dry. Pick by your drying room, not by habit: a room you can keep cool and slow suits dry trim, and a humid or cramped one suits wet trim, so nothing molds while it hangs.
Your drying room picks the trim.
What changes between the two
The leaves are the main difference. Left on, they wrap the flowers like a jacket and slow the dry down. Taken off, the flowers dry faster.
Wet trim. All the trimming happens on chop day. The leaves stand out from the flowers and are easy to reach, but the work is sticky, so keep rubbing alcohol nearby for the scissors. Trimmed pieces dry flat on a mesh rack or hang on short stems, and they dry faster than whole branches.
Dry trim. Chop day is fast: cut, take off the big fan leaves if you like, and hang whole plants or branches. The trim waits until the dry is done, about 7 to 14 days later. The dried leaves curl in toward the flowers, so the trim takes patience, and dried flowers are brittle, so handle them by the stem.
There's a middle road too: strip the big fan leaves at the chop, hang the branches, and trim the small leaves after the dry.
Does wet trim cost smell?
Mostly through the dry, not the scissors. A flower with no leaf around it dries faster, and a fast dry tends to take more of the smell with it. That's the usual reason growers notice a gap. Keep the dry slow and cool, inside the room's lane, and the gap gets small. A sealed drying box that holds the room steady is doing the same slow dry the leaves would otherwise do.
So the question to ask first isn't "wet or dry?" It's "how fast is my room going to dry this?"
Pick by your room, in this order
Read the room before the chop. Use a thermometer and hygrometer at the height things will hang. The lane for a dry is 60 to 70°F and 50 to 60% humidity, with gentle air and no fan aimed at what's hanging.
Cool and steady, inside that lane? Dry trim. The leaves slow the dry for you, and there's no rush on chop day.
Humid, warm, or packed tight with little air? Wet trim. Less leaf means less trapped moisture, and the flowers dry before mold gets its chance. Space them out on the rack so air reaches every side.
Very dry room? Lean the other way: leave more leaf on and hang bigger pieces, so the outside doesn't go crisp while the middle is still wet.
Check the pace either way. If the outside feels crisp by day 3 or 4, it's drying too fast. Slow it down next time with more leaf, bigger pieces or a little more humidity.
What not to do
Don't wet trim and then speed the dry with heat or a fan. That stacks both ways of losing smell on the same harvest.
Don't dry trim in a room you can't control. Leaves full of water in a humid, crowded space are where mold starts.
Don't feed a trimmer material it isn't made for. Wet trimmers and dry trimmers are different machines. The hand-turned trimmer on our shelf takes dried flowers only.
Don't pick a side because someone online swears by it. Their room isn't your room. Run the method your room supports, then judge it in the jar.
When it's something else
You found gray fuzz or mush at harvest: take her down and wet trim, so you can open up and check every flower. See the Bud Rot Survival Guide.
How long to dry, and when it's ready for the jar: see How long do I dry, and how do I know it's ready for the jar?
Deciding when to cut in the first place: see our Harvest Decision Guide.
Curing and storing what you dried: see How to cure and store your harvest.
On our shelf in Worcester: Drying racks, trim bins and a hand-turned dry trimmer are in Harvest, drying & storage. Call (508) 459-9609 or get directions.
Can't keep the drying room at 60 to 70°F and 50 to 60%? A sealed drying cabinet holds it for you. We rent a Cannatrol Cool Cure at the shop, and if you'd rather own one, our FlavorWise CH-172A page has its size, price and what it holds. Every purchase helps fund our free lessons (we earn a small commission).
Keep going
What each rack, tray and trimmer does: see our drying racks and trimming gear shelf guide.
Set the room first and the rest follows. The whole system for a steady grow is written down in the free Stability Playbook. Get the free Stability Playbook
More answers: all grow guides. Every shelf guide and maker feed chart: Grower Resources.